Why children lie and how to manage it

Many parents are challenged by their little ones’ deceptions. Luckily, there’s plenty of ways to respond that encourage kids to be more truthful in future!

Whether it’s a simple fib or a more elaborate untruth, the reality is that kids are likely to tell you a lie somewhere along the way. This might raise some concerns, but understanding why little ones lie and how to respond can help you guide them towards honesty and trustworthiness.

Why do children lie?

Many parents assume kids lie to get something they desire, avoid a consequence or sidestep something they don’t want to do. While these are all usual reasons, there are also some less obvious motivations behind why children might not be straight with you – or at least not fully. These are often linked to their developmental stages and the environments they’re spending time in. Recognising the ‘why’ behind the behaviour is the first step in addressing it effectively. Let’s take a closer look!

Developmental stages

Young children, especially those under six, may not yet grasp the difference between fantasy and reality. They might tell tall tales as part of their imaginative play, rather than to deceive you. As children grow, they start to understand the concept of lying but may still struggle with self-control and the impulse to tell untruths.

Fear of punishment

One of the most common reasons children lie is to avoid punishment. If little ones fear the repercussions of their actions, they might choose to lie to escape immediate consequences, as developmentally, they often think in the present, instead of considering the effects of their actions down the line. This is particularly true in environments or homes where mistakes are met with harsh punishments rather than constructive guidance.

Desire for approval

Children want to be liked and accepted. They might lie to impress their peers or to avoid disappointing their parents and teachers. This need for approval can lead them to stretch the truth or fabricate stories to either fit in or stand out, depending on what they feel pressure to do to be accepted.

Testing boundaries

Sometimes, lying is a way for children to test boundaries, find limits and assert their independence. By bending the truth, they get to explore what they can get away with and how much control they have over their world. This is a relatively normal thing that kids do, but you still have to deal with it to teach little ones that lying isn’t an okay way to do this.

Modelling behaviour

Children learn a great deal from observing the adults around them. If they see parents or other influential figures lying, even in minor ways, they may come to view dishonesty as acceptable behaviour. That’s why it’s fundamental for parents to model the behaviour they want to see in their children.

How to respond when your child lies

Addressing lying effectively requires a balanced approach that combines understanding, discipline and positive reinforcement. Here are some strategies to help you navigate these tricky waters.

A safe home

Ensure your child feels safe and secure enough to tell you the truth. When you discover a lie, it’s natural to feel disappointed or angry. However, reacting with intense emotions can escalate the situation and leave a very negative impression on your child. Harsh punishments that might instil fear rather than respect are best avoided. Instead, try to stay calm and composed, addressing the lie in a manner that is firm but understanding. This encourages proper lines of communication and assures your child that honesty is valued, even when the truth is difficult.

Emphasise honesty

It’s always worth having conversations about why honesty is important, tailored to your child’s age of course. It’s good to explain how trust is built and maintained, and how lies can damage relationships. Use stories and examples, if you can, to illustrate the impact of lying and the value of being upfront. Help your child take responsibility for their actions. This doesn’t mean shaming them for lying, but rather guiding them to understand the effects of their dishonesty and encouraging them to make amends where possible.

Be truthful

Children are like sponges, picking up and mimicking the smallest of behaviours from the adults around them. With that in mind, try to avoid telling ‘white lies’ in front of your child, and if you do, explain why it was a mistake. Demonstrating honesty in your actions is the most effective way to reinforce the importance of truthfulness as children respond best to what they see as an example, not what they are instructed to do.

Praise truth-telling

When your child tells the truth, especially in difficult situations, praise their honesty. Positive reinforcement can be a powerful motivator for us all, and this is especially the case with kids. Acknowledging their courage in owning up to mistakes helps build their confidence and reinforces that something good happens when you tell the truth, encouraging the behaviour you want to see.

Problem-solving skills

Sometimes, children lie because they don’t know how to handle a situation. If you can teach your little one problem-solving skills and provide them with tools to cope with challenges, this can hugely reduce their need to lie as a way of managing difficult scenarios.

Clear expectations and consequences

Make sure your child understands the family’s values around honesty and the consequences of lying. These consequences should be reasonable and related to the lie, rather than punitive. For example, if they lied about finishing their homework, the consequence might be extra time dedicated to completing it under supervision. Consistency in your responses to lying is crucial. If your reactions are unpredictable, it may confuse your child and undermine your efforts to promote honesty. Set clear rules and follow through with the agreed-upon consequences every time.

If lying becomes a chronic issue or is accompanied by other troubling behaviours, it might be beneficial to seek help from a child psychologist. However, in general, lying is a behaviour that can be managed with the right parental approach. Remember, children are simply learning and growing, and a measured, empathetic and well-informed response can guide them towards a more honest path.

Image Credit: Shutterstock